Gameplay is a 10. The best feeling game in the series.
Maps are a solid 8. Not the best maps in the series but very good and more are coming.
Graphics/Sound for me are a 9. The game looks how I’d want a modern Halo to look. It won’t blow your mind but the art style is so good that it will still look good years down the line.
Weapons/Meta/Competitive Potential is a solid 9.5 for me. This is the best game in terms of sandbox and competitive balance since Halo 3.
Battle Pass/Cosmetic System is currently a 5. I think 343 knows it isn’t what we want and they’ll fix it over time.
Overall the game is a solid 9.5 for me with the potential to be a damn near perfect Halo game with some fixes.