Microsoft-Activision-Blizzard Discussion Thread |OT3| - Sony bends the knee!

Amazes me that the CMA asked for more time with a straight face when they wasted no time in calling out the EU.

4 Likes

Also might be a good idea to not respond to a 6 page document from Microsoft with a 500 page response of case law, seems like they’re stalling.

1 Like

From what I have read it does seem like they are stalling, which, if you come out so certain of your decision after over a year of invesitgation, you should have your counter points at the ready if you had complete confidence in your decision.

5 Likes

Case law and legal precedent is their defence. I don’t think that’s necessarily an issue. Their obvious delay tactics though point to collusion. I get that the expedited timetable is not usual but they should not have an issue with it given their defence of this isn’t novel. It’s much harder for MS than the CMA . Yet the CMA are the ones crying for more time.

6 Likes

If I was one of those CMA lawyers Id be on indeed tonight :skull:

1 Like

CMA

11 Likes
22 Likes

It would be wondeful to get the Canada and New Zealand decisions the CMA tried to use as stall tactics before the 2nd case management hearing.

17 Likes

This was just like that good cop bad cop approach. Microsoft’s lawyers were to the point and the Activision lawyers were lashing out with fury. I do wonder if the hearing is only expected to be 6 to 10 days does Microsoft still need to renegotiate or extend the closing date or is there a grace period added.

1 Like

I dont think decisions are made in trial, are they? I thought a decision would be post trial and aiming for before September.

Edit *After reviewing the previous M&A cases before CAT, it looks like their previous quickest decision after an appeal was 4 weeks. Im guessing the expedited case will receieve an expedited decision that will aet a new peecedent, but I wouldnt count on somwthing that week or anything. I would suggest that it seems like it would come before September.

I’m guessing MS and ABK will have to negotiate an extension to their deal considering the outcome of today; wonder what will come out of it. With how hard they are pushing I’m guessing it’s in both parties’ interest to keep this deal alive and keep moving forward.

1 Like

Hopefully after today the CMA comes to reasoning and unblock this deal. This whole speedy trial seemed like it was geared to avoid renegotiating. Even the judge urged them realizing the size and global impact of the deal which the CMA seemed oblivious to and treated like a common thing.

3 Likes

Is there a recording available online for what occurred today?

Or even a supercut of the event. That’d be nice. It honestly sounds like the gaming media didn’t even tune in so you need independent games media to shine a light on it.

2 Likes

It said recordings were illegal so while I’m sure there are some, I doubt you’ll see one easily.

3 Likes

Recording of the event was forbidden. They had a disclaimer at the bottom of the teams window. But I’m not sure if cat themselves make a recording available

3 Likes

The best you’re going to do is probably this:

Florian Mueller on Twitter: “It’s a wrap: almost 4 hours. CMA is losing! I know that countless questions were asked. Please let me first get something to eat. I even had to rebook a flight to be in front of my computer in time for the hearing. I can’t answer a huge number of questions individually. But…” / Twitter

(Many many tweets)

6 Likes

Best to check the CAT website to see if there will be an upload. This was probably their most viewed stream. Maybe Destin will try to get something since he’s content revolves around this. It certainly was fun watching. The Microsoft and ABK lawyers totally dominated.

3 Likes

Didn’t CMA post tweets during the conference? Imagine writing them making them look good like “We are getting the judge by its throat. We are good people.”

1 Like

The CMA has not posted anything in the last four days.

Something that I personally think is funny. Florian has more followers than the CMA.

6 Likes