Naah, reflections all over the place isn’t an upgrade. Which one looks “better” is definitely more subjective and the only reason why it’s brought up because this is an upgrade and its only being assessed from that perspective, not that it looks good or bad.
You can go on YouTube and find hundreds of videos of GTA, RDR2, Skyrim all having a rainstorm on a sunny day, cranking up reflections everywhere and posting it as “Raytracing Boost 4K ULTRA EPIC SETTINGS” lol, it’s the puddle gate all over again. I’d wait for the proper Digital Foundry analysis of the Next gen version to get the full picture, I’m confident the upgrade is still gonna be significant enough and it’ll look crazy good.