People expect free game with their gold sub now so they dont want the negatives from dropping it but they also want people to move to GP so they provide the bare minimum to say they are still providing you with something
It will go away eventually, likely turned into some other GP tier like was rumored a few months ago
They keep it around because Sony has it, and XBL Gold can’t be perceived to offer less than PS Plus until GP hits a certain threshold that they can get rid of Gold.
Money, they want that recurring $60/year that xbox live gold contributes and removing GWG will cause outrage. I think solution imo is to create gamepass basic which gives you online play and a select amount of games that are on gamepass.
At this point, it’s obvious GamePass has made sure there probably won’t be any real huge titles on it again, but as pointed out they and Sony are basically in a standoff of who’s going to drop the free games with an online sub first.
Sony very obviously started it as a loss leader to get people to subscribe to PSPlus originally, then MS eventually followed with GWG when the PS plus games started gaining a lot of attention. They’ve both majorly slimmed down the offerings. Depends on who blinks first at this point.