As suggested on the latest Xbox Era Podcast, I’m spinning off my question into its own thread.
Inspired by a Kinda Funny video, I want to hear what games the Xbox Era community thinks defined each Xbox generation. Not necessarily your favourites, but rather the games that helped give each console it’s identity.
For reference, here’s Kinda Funny’s list:
Original Xbox:
-
Halo (Bungie/Microsoft)
-
Halo 2 (Bungie/Microsoft)
-
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic (BioWare/Lucas Arts)
-
Ninja Gaiden (Team Ninja/Tecmo)
-
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory (Ubisoft)
Xbox 360:
-
Halo 3 (Bungie/Microsoft)
-
Gears of War (Epic/Microsoft)
-
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Infinity Ward/Activision)
-
Mass Effect (Bioware/Microsoft)
-
Fable 2 (Lionhead/Microsoft)
Xbox One:
-
Sunset Overdrive (Insomniac/Microsoft)
-
Forza Horizon 4 (Playground Games/Microsoft)
-
Halo Master Chief Collection (343/Microsoft)
-
Cuphead (Studio MDHR)
-
Ori and the Blind Forest (Moon Studios/Microsoft)
Personally, I think their OG and 360 lists are spot on.
There would be no Xbox without Halo. What else is there to say? Halo 2 set the standard for online gaming, and Halo 3 pushed it further, creating a true social platform (forget Sony first-party games, this was the first big photo mode I remember).
What Halo was to the original Xbox, Gears of War was to the 360. It opened the door for a whole generation of cover shooters and Unreal Engine games.
KotOR cemented the Xbox as the platform of WRPGs. That same team at BioWare would then partner with Microsoft to create Mass Effect. Mass Effect 1 is a game that feels distinctly Xbox to me. Everything from the HUD to the overall aesthetic just feel very intune with the system.
The Xbox One generation is where I struggle a bit. It doesn’t have its equivalent to Halo or Gears. Microsoft’s first party also didn’t put out any WRPGs for the first time. It was a very different generation, but one with a few gems.
Killer Instinct deserves credit for being one of the first service games done right. It’s a game that went from rendering at 720p with 6 characters at launch to rendering at 4K with 29 characters in a few years.
To touch on a few others, Forza Horizon really came into its own during the Xbox One generation. While TitanFall didn’t become Halo or Gears tier, it was a great early title. Sunset Overdrive is one of my favourites, and Sea of Thieves proves Rare never left.
With my commentary out of the way, what would your list look like?