I guess the standards were so low that a 99% multiplatform show that wasn’t a complete snoozefest is considered “amazing” now. 
As a multiplatform show it was a C+ but as a “SGF” show from a platform holder it was very disappointing IMO, as someone earlier wrote if this was an SGF-Not E3 Xbox show…oh boy…but now that it’s a Sony show some journalists and a part of the PS community are trying to convince themselves that it was not a bad Playstation show. 